Sandra has a post about an interesting case of a person who commited a crime (and was acquitted) while sleepwalking. The term “sleep disorder” was used as a defence.
But, is it a disorder at all? It naturally occurs in a proportion of human population. It is called a disorder because it does not happen to everyone and it can be dangerous for the sleepwalker or the people around him/her. Nobody is really trying to treat it, except for making sure that habitual sleepwalkers have a safe environment in which to walk at night (multiple complicated locks on the doors, etc).
Yes, you are completely unconscious, you cannot plan what to do once you are asleep and walking, you have no awareness of what you are doing while you are sleepwalking, and you have no recollection of what you did once you wake up. This would make acquittal a correct decision, without any need to invoke a ‘disorder’.
Yet, a person who would commit crime when awake will commit one when sleepwalking, and person who would never do so while awake is unlikely to get started while asleep.
Michael Rack does not have much on the topic on his blog, and neither does Michael Breus, but there is more here.
This is also similar to the case of sexsomnia.
So, what do you think? Is this a good alibi? If you did something bad while unconscious, would you want to be acquitted?
My Homepage
My homepage is at http://coturnix.org. It is temporarily stripped to minimal information, but more will come soon.Grab my RSS feed:
-
Join 1,499 other subscribers
Search This Blog:
Archives
Categories
Recent Comments:
Bora Zivkovic on Morning at Triton Angie Lindsay Ma on Morning at Triton Linda chamblee on Morning at Triton Jekyll » Blog… on The Big Announcement, this tim… Mike H on The Big Announcement, this tim… -
Recent Posts
Top Posts
- Save the Mountain Walrus
- Books: "The Sex Lives Of Teenagers" by Lynn Ponton
- Who are you, dear readers?
- Math 2.0 Webinar tonight
- ScienceOnline2012 – interview with Sean Ekins
- LaTeX fan? You can now use your favourite software to submit manuscripts to PLoS ONE
- Bush promises $350 million for Neglected Tropical Diseases
- Clock Classics: It all started with the plants
- Now, this is Open Science!
- BIO101 - Cell Structure
@BoraZ on Twitter:
Tweets by BoraZCC licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.PayPal

Sitemeter






Pingback: Bering in Mind: Sex, Sleep and the Law: When Nocturnal Genitals Pose a Moral Dilemma « Simon Studio Analysis