In the comments to this recent post, Pedro Beltao points out his recent post – Opening up the scientific process – which I would suggest you read.
First reaction will probably be – ah, how idealistic! But it will make you think, I believe. Many elements are already happening, e.g., open-source journals, open comments on online journal articles, as well as blogs and wikis that report research in real time, e.g., Useful Chem Experiments, RRResearch and UsefulChem Wiki.
The world of academic science is slow-moving and resistant to change, but it is already changing nonetheless. And, as each element of Pedro’s model slowly changes, the system as a whole is bound to change, perhaps beyond recognition. If publishing is a public business, the way authority is gained in the field will change. Instead of counting a number of Science/Nature papers, serach committees will be able to take a much deeper look at any individiual’s work and thought. While science will remain intensely competitive, the field where competition occurs will move away from big journals, citation indices and into the public sphere online. Then, teh business of science will stop being “production of manuscrupts” and become, yet again in history, “production of knowledge”.
So, while it will take time, effort and adjusting (and fixing the unforseeable side-effects), and perhaps a change of generation (or two), I do not this that something like this or this or what Pedro is describing is unrealistic.
My Homepage
My homepage is at http://coturnix.org. It is temporarily stripped to minimal information, but more will come soon.Grab my RSS feed:
-
Join 1,496 other subscribers
Search This Blog:
Archives
Categories
Recent Comments:
Bora Zivkovic on Morning at Triton Angie Lindsay Ma on Morning at Triton Linda chamblee on Morning at Triton Jekyll » Blog… on The Big Announcement, this tim… Mike H on The Big Announcement, this tim… -
Recent Posts
Top Posts
- Clock Tutorial #14: Interpreting The Phase Response Curve
- Elephants in zoos
- Encouraging authors to place their papers into open repositories
- Psychology of Political Ideology
- ScienceOnline2012 – interview with Jessica Morrison
- Genomics of Emerging Infectious Disease PLoS Collection
- Sean Carrol Interview
- Teaching Biology Lab
- Friday Weird Sex Blogging - a cop-out again, and 15 minutes late...
- High-school student models the circadian clock
@BoraZ on Twitter:
Tweets by BoraZCC licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.PayPal

Sitemeter
Did you know the origin of the phrase “Every time you masturbate (or do whataver in the context), God kills a kitten”? I just found out that 








